PastPresented

GEORGE NEWBY: THE POETICAL PARSON OF BORROWDALE
To home page

In trying to trace the history of the house built by Mary Barker at Rosthwaite in Borrowdale, Cumbria, in 1816-7, now the Scafell Hotel, I was advised by the current landlord that it had at one time served as Borrowdale's parsonage. Close inspection suggests that this was only for a few months, while the parsonage house near the chapel was being renovated, but the parson (or more properly, perpetual curate) in question turned out to have one significant factor in common with Miss Barker- whom he never met- so he merits a little exploration of his life.
 

Later evidence such as census returns indicates that George Newby was born at Ulverston, Lancashire, in 1800. Unfortunately 1800 baptisms are missing from the Lancashire OnLine Parish Clerk project, so more work is needed!

Clergy of the Church of England Database, [my summary of entries 1823-34]:
George Newby, born around 1800 at Ulverston in the Furness district of Lancashire, was educated for the Church at the then-new St. Bees College on the west coast of Cumberland, where he qualified in 1823. He was ordained as a deacon on 3 Oct 1824 by Bishop Blomfield of Chester. He served as curate at Colton near Ulverston for the next three years, then on 26 Jan 1828 Blomfield appointed him as stipendiary curate at Muncaster in Cumberland, where he remained until he was appointed by Bishop Percy of Carlisle as curate of Arthuret on 20 Aug 1833.

Meanwhile, in Borrowdale:
Jane Platt (editor), "The Diocese of Carlisle, 1814-1855", 2015 [my summary]
In the late 1820s, when the newly-appointed Bishop of Carlisle, Hugh Percy, surveyed his parishes, he made no comment on the chapel (which had been rebuilt in 1824-5, following careless repairs around 1813) but observed that "The Glebe House is unfit for the residence of the Incumbent".

Find A Grave, (Borrowdale: George Newby, 1872), (event 1834)
"MARY HIS WIFE, WHO DIED JULY 9TH 1834 IN THE 36TH YEAR OF HER AGE. And was Interred at Longtown."

FindMyPast (from Arthuret parish register), (event 1834)
"Mary Newby, Female, ... Burial date 14 Jul 1834, Burial place Arthuret, Cumberland, England"

Cumberland Pacquet, 22 Jul 1834:
Deaths ...
"At Longtown, on the 11th inst., Mary wife of the Rev. G. Newby, curate of Arthuret, aged 37 years."

Oxford Chronicle, 6 Jan 1838:
Deaths ...
"Aged 78, the Rev. William Parsable, 32 years perpetual curate of Borrowdale, Cumberland, and twelve years vicar of Gilcrux, Cumberland."

Ancestry.com, (event 1838):
"George Newby ... Marriage Date: 30 Jan 1838. Marriage Place: Arthuret, Cumberland, England. Spouse: Margaret James ..."

Cumberland Pacquet, 27 May 1838:
"On Thursday last the Rev. George Newby was licensed, by the Lord Bishop of Carlisle, to the perpetual curacy of Borrowdale, on the presentation of the Rev. J. Lynn, A.M., vicar of Crosthwaite."

Find A Grave, (Borrowdale: George Newby, 1872), (event 1840)
"MARY ANN THEIR DAUGHTER WHO DIED AUGUST 14TH 1840, AGED 16 YEARS"

Census return- Cumberland, Crosthwaite parish, Rosthwaite, 1841:
[Ages of adults are given to the nearest 5 years:]


Bulmer's History & Directory of West Cumberland, 1883 [referring to 1842]:
BORROWDALE ...
"A commodious residence was added in 1842 at a cost of £900, including the site, of which sum £800 was the bequest of the late Joseph Fisher, Esq., and £200 was received from Queen Anne's Bounty, thus leaving a balance of £100, which is invested in the 3 per cents. for the benefit of the living."
OR
Mannix & Whellan "History, Gazetteer & Directory of Cumberland", 1847:
... "a commodious parsonage, erected, near the chapel, at a cost of about £1000. (including £100. for the site), £800. of which were contributed by Abraham Fisher, Esq., and the remaining £200. obtained from queen Anne's bounty."

Carlisle Journal, 24 Dec 1842:
Deaths ...
"At the Parsonage, Borrowdale, on Thursday, the 15th inst., Margaret, the beloved wife of the Rev. Mr. Newby, aged 44 years."

Find A Grave, (Borrowdale: George Newby, 1872), (events 1842)
"MARGARET HIS SECOND WIFE, WHO DIED DECR. 19TH 1842 AGED 44 YEARS.
ALSO OF MARY JANE DAUGHTER OF THE above George & Margaret Newby, WHO DIED JULY 7TH 1842, Aged 10 Months."

Cambridge Chronicle, 7 Jan 1843:
Deaths ...
"Aged 44, Margaret, wife of the Rev. George Newby, perpetual curate of Borrowdale, Cumberland."

Rev. George Newby, "Pleasures of Melancholy, in three parts", 1843 or 1842:
There is no date on the printed edition of Newby's first poetical publication, over a hundred pages long including explanatory notes. The British Library has catalogued it as 1842, but the evidence for that choice is unknown. The title page does tell us a little, first confirming Newby's status:
"CURATE OF BORROWDALE

Keswick:
PRINTED BY T. BAILEY AND SON."

The poem is dedicated to Abraham Fisher Esq., of Seatoller, "AS A SMALL TOKEN OF GRATITUDE AND ESTEEM"; it begins:

YE sleek-faced happy mortals, who are bless'd
With minds of sameness, equable and smooth,
Like a smith's anvil— not to be impress'd
With what is formed thereon— ye'll deem uncouth
My Muse, which sings the Melancholy mind,
And its sad joys, unseen, assays to find.
Yet if perchance, from your ethereal height,
Where shine eternal suns, and know no night;
Nor fogs nor storms, along the calm serene,
E'er dim your fair horizon's changeless scene;
Ye view this grosser region's thick-spread gloom,
Where silent MELANCHOLY breathes his doom:—
Know that a pleasing sadness prompts the lay,
Which marks the bright spots of his cheerless day.
...


Detailed notes follow, indicating that the poem was at least partly written in 1840 (part III, which features Napoleon Bonaparte, was written when his ashes were belatedly brought from St. Helena to France) and perhaps partly in 1839 (the year Prime Minister Melbourne presented Robert Owen, whom Newby refers to as "the founder of socialism," to Queen Victoria). They also reveal (with direct reference to Owen's educational system at New Lanark):
"my firm conviction, that when knowledge is substituted for religion, or avowedly separated from it,— more especially in any system of education,— it will add little to the happiness of mankind, in any rank or condition of life, particularly in the lower grades of society; and prove but a feeble defence against the assaults of temptation and the inroads of vice."
The book closes with two short poems,"LINES TO AN INFANT ON THE EVE OF HIS FIRST BIRTH-DAY" and "THE LOVE OF GOD".


Cumberland Pacquet, 9 May 1843:
"
Just Published,
PLEASURES OF MELANCHOLY,— A Poem (in Three Parts), by the Rev. GEORGE NEWBY, Curate of Borrowdale, Price 4s.
Sold by T. Bailey and Son, Keswick and Cockermouth; Scot and Benson, Carlisle; H. Hoodless, Wigton; R. Gibson, Whitehaven; Mr. Soulby, Ulverston; and may be had on application to the Author.
  April 13th, 1843."

Cumberland Pacquet, 30 May 1843:
"THE PLEASURES OF MELANCHOLY.- This is a handsome volume of poetry from the press of Messrs. Baily and Son of Cockermouth, the typographical design of which does them much credit. The work itself is a classical production from the pen of the Rev. George Newby, curate of Borrowdale, and may fairly claim to be ranked amongst the first poetic compositions in our local literature. There is that degree of ease and freedom in the versification which is always peculiarly pleasing to the poetic reader, and there is moreover a total absence of all endeavour at studied effect. The descriptive powers of the author are of no mean order, of which following graphic sketch of some of the finest scenery in nature will at once serve to convince the reader:—
The Lowdore streamlet, fainting in the heat,
And softly trickling to its dark retreat;—
Then slowly pac'd acoss the open glades,
Still ling'ring whiles beneath the wood's thick shades,
Till the wide prospect open'd on the sight,
As rose the gentle breeze upon this height.
And oh ! how grateful to the chasten'd heart
The pure delight its blended charms impart !
Whoe'er by Nature taught, unmoved, surveys
The Panoramic scene she here displays !
The prostrate Derwent, courting to explore
The many windings of his varied shore—
The lofty Skiddaw, with peculiar grace,
Majestic, tow'ring o'er his giant race;
Now on the glist'ning waves inverted laid,
In all his placid dignity pourtray'd—
The op'ning vale, where Bassenthwaite displays
His lengthen'd lake, and wood-embosom'd bays—
The sweeping mountains, in their southward range,
Impending o'er the low, romantic Grange,
Their wild confusion curving into line,
As, with terrific mien, they circling join,
Where, clad in matchless beauty, Nature reigns,
Supremely grand, o'er Borrowdale's domains;
Their litt'ring summits, rearward, waving high,
Far as the two-topp'd Scawfell meets the sky—
The dale below, by lake and mountain 'closed,
Small in extent, but with nice art compos'd—
Of rip'ning corn, and meadows strew'd with hay—
Of scatter'd cots along the winding way—
While, issuing from the mountains' massy pile,
The gleaming river, ling'ring, sports awhile
Beneath the gliding sun— then gently teems
To the calm lake, its smoot commingling streams—
And the mix'd woods, their hues of varied green,
In rich profusion, scatter o'er the scene,
Which, now transform'd, in darker image lies,
Whose faintest sketch my feeble hand defies.
At first, a dense impenetrable cloud
En wraps the valley in its vap'ry shroud;
And, far or near, in vain the straining eye
Attempts each well-known object to descry—
High mountain— lake— and mead— and tree—
Are vanished all— a vast extended sea,
Which seems, afar, to reach the lengthen'd skies,
In misty dimness, now, before thee lies.
A melancholy look its waters wear—
Yet tranquil and compos'd— no tumult's there—
Upon the gloomy calm, reflected dim,
Thy spirit sees its own sad image swim—
Accordant feelings prompt spontaneous smiles
Of sympathetic joy, when num'rous isles,
In peaceful loveliness and look serene
Surpassing aught fair Nature's choicest scene
Can boast— or fond creative Fancy prize—
Upon thy sight in sudden beauty rise.
There, good Saint Herbert, dedicate to God,
Might deign to fix his heav'n-fore-stall'd abode—
Secluded, weep o'er all the ceaseless strife
That swells the wide tempestuous sea of life—
High converse hold with Spirits of the Blest,
And "pray his soul" to everlasting rest.
Fit emblem of whose aspirations high,
And heav'n-ward tendencies, the op'ning sky,
Clear and serene, the sun-capt summit shews
Of yonder mountain shining o'er the gross
Dense vapour.— So when guilt's deep-piercing sting
Goads on the sinner to remorse and sorrowing;
And fearful doubts of heav'ns free pard'ning grace
Forbid weak Reason's falt'ring steps to trace
Thro' the dark mists of Penitence— the way
To Virtue's peaceful realms— a mild bright way,
Far from the thorny wreath of "Him who died
That man might live," shoots forth— the cheering guide
To heaven's high mercy seat, of whoso, straight,
In honest faith pursues the gracious light.
Or, wand'ring thro' the world's wide wilderness,
When mis'ry sinks, forlorn and comfortless,—
Hope's bright effulgence, breaking o'er the gloom,
Will, haply, thus the dreary waste illume;
The wretch sustain; and energy supply
To gain the region of a happier sky.
So, when the hov'ring soul, appall'd, surveys
Death's gloomy vale, where all the countless ways
Of life, converging, vanish from the sight,
Lost in the dismal shades of endless night—
The radiant beams of boundless love divine,
From Calv'ry's holy mount, serenely shine;
And o'er the awful gulf, perchance, display
The peaceful mansions of celestial day.

[the above is quoted from pages 26-31 of the book]

This poem is altogether very much to our liking: the Pleasures of Melancholy are beautifully unfolded, and the language employed for that purpose is calculated to please, not to encourage despondency. Indeed there is nothing sombre or gloomy about the poem.Though this may be the first, we trust it will not be the last contribution which the author will make to our stock of local literature: he is evidently possessed of poetic genius, and will find other subjects to court his attention, some of which, we hope, will embrace a more extended description of the beautiful scenery amid which he dwells."

Cumberland Pacquet, 25 Jun 1844:
Fundraising advert for the proposed memorial in Crosthwaite Church to the late Robert Southey; subscribers so far include:
"Rev. George Newby, Borrowdale — — 0 10 0" [i.e. ten shillings]

Census return- Cumberland, Crosthwaite parish, Village of Chapel, 1851:

Cause Papers in the Diocesan Courts of the Archbishopric of York, 1853-4 [catalogue entry]:
Reference:CHANC.CP.1853/2
Repository:Borthwick Institute GB 193
Court:Chancery
Case:Benefice cases (drukenness)
Details:5 Pieces; No deposition; Has libel; No sentence
Outcome: -
Date: 1853 — 1854

Participant:Office
Role:plaintiff
Details:undefined

Participant:George Newby
Role:defendant
Details:male; Clerk (Reverend)
Employment:Curate of Borrowdale
Location:Crosthwaite (Cumberland)
Place(s):Borrowdale (Borrowdale) : chapelry

Participant:George Gill Mouncey
Role:promoting parties
Details:male; Gentleman
Location:Carlisle (Carlisle) : city

Participant:George Lawton
Role:prosecution proctor
Details:male; The Elder
Employment:Notary Public

Participant:William Lawton
Role:prosecution proctor
Details:male
Employment:Notary Public

Participant:George Lawton
Role:defence proctor
Details:male; The Younger
Employment:Notary Public

Associated Places
Location:Ulverston (Lancashire)
Place(s):Ulverston (Ulverston) : ecclesiastical parish
Location:Crosthwaite (Cumberland)
Place(s):Borrowdale (Borrowdale) : chapelry
Castle Lodge (Castle Lodge) : undefined
Location:Brougham (Westmorland)
Place(s):Brougham (Brougham) : ecclesiastical parish
Location:Morland (Westmorland)
Place(s):Morland (Morland) : ecclesiastical parish
Location:Aspatria (Cumberland)
Place(s):Aspatria (Aspatria) : ecclesiastical parish
Location:Crosby Ravensworth (Westmorland)
Place(s):Crosby Ravensworth (Crosby Ravensworth) : ecclesiastical parish

Kendal Mercury, 26 Dec 1854:
Just Published, Price 2s. 6d.,
HENLLYWARC; or, "THE DRUID'S TEMPLE," near Keswick: A Poem. By the Rev. GEORGE NEWBY, Incumbent of Borrowdale, Author of Pleasures of Melancholy.
London: Longman, Brown, Green, and Longmans.
Keswick: Ivison.


Henllywarc (available free online via the Internet Archive) is a narrative poem set principally in ancient Britain, with voluminous explanatory notes. Contrary to the implication of the title-page, Henllywarc is not the ancient monument (illustrated in a nice little engraving) ...
The Druids' Temple, aka Castlerigg stone circle
... but the name of the central character: dog-Welsh for "old commanding ruler", a king brought low by the machinations of the Druid priests. There is a real, probably-historical 6th century prince-bard of Rheged (the post-Roman kingdom including much of modern Cumbria) named Llywarch Hen, but the poem's chronology is, to put it politely, creative. Also, Newby does not make the slightest effort to conceal the main point of his story:
"Say, is it thus that "Babylon the Great"
Still reigns sole Arbitress of Ireland's fate?
In her false prodigies, her pompous rites,
Her penances, her mass, her gorgeous sights—
"All her abominations"— may we trace
The Druids' influence o'er the Celtic race?

THE CHURCH
There are within the Church again have sought
Her long-discarded robes, to deck her out
With those false arts and meretricious wares,
Once lured mankind and kept them in her snares:
There are, her own chaste garb would rudely tear,
With these, away— severely strip her bare,
And leave her, unlike all God's gifts to man,
A work of chance, an end without a plan.
Is not her spirit marred, when Party deems,
Her pow'r is centred in its own extremes ?
Shall we deny that pure Religion can,
In faith, "bow down a Nation as one man?"
No— see, through Mammon's foldings gleams the light,
Marks her triumphant in her own meek might !"

[the above is quoted from pages 23-4 of the book]


Carlisle Patriot, 30 Aug 1856:
Recently Published, Price 2s. 6d.
HENLLYWARC ; or, the Druid's Temple near Keswick: a Poem. By the Rev. GEORGE NEWBY, Incumbent of Borrowdale.
London: LONGMAN & Co.   Keswick: JAMES IVISON.

Carlisle Journal, 5 Oct 1860:
"A TRULY VALUABLE MEDICAL DISCOVERY.
ISAAC FEARON, FARMER, BRAITHWAITE, near Keswick, Cumberland, has discovered a method of Cure for many Distressing Complaints, the efficacy of which he has tested for years upon many persons in his immediate neighbourhood
...
The following highly respectable gentlemen of the neighbourhood have kindly permitted reference to be made to them, viz.—
    ...
    Rev. George Newby, Borrowdale Parsonage.
    Thomas Simpson, Esq., Borrowdale.
    ..."

Yorkshire Post, 25 Aug 1932 [looking back to 1861]:
"Seventy-one years ago Grange Church or Chapel was set down in the midst of Borrowdale, which already had a church three miles higher up the valley. The second church was built entirely against the wishes of the then vicar, the Rev. George Newby, who ignored it.
These facts were given at a Grange garden party in aid of church funds by the Vicar, the Rev. C.D. Fothergill. The church endowment, he said, brought in 11s. 1¼d. weekly. Therefore no minister would undertake the living. When the Rev. George Newby died each of the ten succeeding ministers, including himself, allowed themselves to be trapped into what did not exist, namely, the perpetual curacy of Grange." [There is a more detailed summary of the story in the Penrith Observer, 30 Aug 1932, which explains, among other things, that while Newby was vicar of Borrowdale, worship at the Grange chapel was conducted by the Rev. T.D. Harford Battersby of St. John's, Keswick]

Crockford's Clerical Directory, 1868:
NEWBY, George, Borrowdale Parsonage, Crossthwaite, Keswick.- St. Bees; Deac. 1824, Pr. 1825. P.C. of Borrowdale, Dio. Carl. 1838. (Patron V. of Crossthwaite; Glebe, 2 acres; P.C.'s Inc. 80l; Pop. 422.) Author, Pleasures of Melancholy (a Poem), Keswick, 1842; Henllyware, or the Druid's Temple near Keswick (a poem), Longmans, 1854.

Ulverston Mirror, 8 Jul 1871:
"PRESENTATION TO A CLERGYMAN.- The Reverend George Newby, for thirty-three years incumbent of Borrowdale, and brother to Mr. Newby, of Fountain-street, in this town, having recently resigned his pastoral charge, his late parishioners resolved, as a mark of their appreciation of his past evangelical labours, to present him with a suitable testimonial. Accordingly a few friends met at Mr. Newby's house, at Keswick, on Saturday, when Mr. Wren, of Seathwaite, delivered an address to the following effect:- "I have great pleasure in presenting you, in the name and through the liberality of your parishioners, with these useful and ornamental articles, and also this purse of gold, as a token of respect and esteem for your long and valuable services extending over upwards of thirty-three years. I hope you may live many years to enjoy the use of them; trusting that the hours which the hands of the time-piece silently point out may forcibly remind you and each of us of the rapid flight of time, and of the necessity of preparing for eternity." The testimonial included a handsomely chased tea and coffee service, an elegant time-piece on a stand of black and grey marble, supplied by Mr. Birkett, of Keswick; and a purse of sovereigns. On the timepiece and tea-pot were the following inscriptions:- "Presented to the Rev. G. Newby by his parishioners in Borrowdale as a token of respect after 33 years of service." Mr. Newby, jun. read, on behalf of his father, a suitable reply."

Whitehaven News, 6 Jul 1871:
[Probably the original from which the above Ulverston report was adapted, and which includes the "suitable reply" (but the available library copy is in bad condition):] "My dear friends and parishioners, I am quite unable to thank you as I ought; let me, therefore, hope you will take the will for the deed, and accept my heartfelt thanks for your great liberality and kindness, at the munificent expression of which I am so completely astonished, that words fail to convey my sense of that which is to me a most profound source of pride and satisfaction. I really was not aware that I had so many kind friends among you. I have done nothing worthy to merit such a tribute except possessing the wish to do my duty in that situation which I deeply regret I am unable to fill longer. I can only thank you for your very liberal and splendid gift, and assure you of my hope that it will be preserved for many years to come in remembrance of this [?day]. I beg to offer to Messrs. Wren and Holliday my [illegible] for the trouble they have taken in this matter, and I [illegible] all that this very liberal gift will [illegible] my forced withdrawal from what was the [illegible] heart, in serving you as the clergyman of Borrowdale [illegible] I may still live a little while longer to enjoy [?this] very splendid present, to preserve your goodwill in my [illegible] and to enjoy your kindness."

Soulby's Ulverston Advertiser, 2 Jan 1873:
Deaths:
"On the 26th ult, at Keswick, the Rev. George Newby, for many years incumbent of Borrowdale, aged 72 years."

Find A Grave, (Borrowdale: George Newby), 1872
"IN MEMORY OF THE REV. GEORGE NEWBY, 33 years Incumbent of this Parish, WHO DIED DECR. 25TH 1872, AGED 72 YEARS ..."

Soulby's Ulverston Advertiser, 29 Apr 1875:
"A TRULY VALUABLE MEDICAL DISCOVERY.
ISAAC FEARON, FARMER, BRAITHWAITE, near Keswick, Cumberland, has discovered a method of Cure for many Distressing Complaints, the efficacy of which he has tested for more than thirty years upon hundreds of persons in various parts of the country
...
The following highly respectable gentlemen have permitted references to be made to them, viz:—
    Rev. G. Newby, Borrowdale Parsonage.
    Thomas Simpson, Esq., Borrowdale.
    ..."